top of page

Don’t Look Away

Writer: Gael MacLean
Gael MacLean
9 hours ago
12 min read

The cost of remembering


A group of village children stand in a dusty yard by bamboo fences and huts, looking at the camera in bright sunlight.

The File


When you spend time in places where nobody speaks your language, you learn to get by without it. You watch eyes. You use your hands. You read people’s bodies and they read yours, and children are better at it than anyone.


In the camps on the Thai/Burma border the kids found my recorder before they found me. It had small lights, red and green, that blinked with the sound, and they could not get enough of them. Most had never seen anything electronic. In the remote camps not many had seen skin like mine either, so there was a lot to look at, and they took their time. The camera stayed in the bag until they were done.


When you looked at those children, they looked back. They didn’t ask for anything.


One girl was seven, maybe eight. She sat on a bench against a post with her arm along the rail and a string knotted at her throat. While the others giggled at the lights, she watched. There was a stillness in her, and a kind of knowing that a child that age shouldn’t have. I never learned her name.


I won’t say which camp it was, or when. A face, a place and a date would be enough to find her.


I was also recording interviews on that trip, through a translator. The adults talked into the microphone and I followed what I could from their faces. Afterward I spent weeks with the translator in a border town. It was the burning season, when people who don’t own the land clear the underbrush in the forests to plant their food before the rains, and the smoke gets so thick you can’t see across the street. We worked through every interview until it was fully translated out of the Karen. Most of it was what the military had done to them. Those stories belong to the people who told them, and I’ll leave them where they were told.


Her photograph went into a file with the others, and it stayed there for years. I told myself I was protecting those kids. I didn’t want to use them for anything. That was partly true. The rest of it is that looking at the pictures meant remembering where those children were, and that most of them were never going to leave.


The Song


Before the song there were books. I went looking for the journalists who were getting the truth out of these places, and I would read a chapter and put the book down. The truth was hard to read.


So I wrote a song, trying to put what I was thinking and feeling into words. It’s something I have had to tell myself all my life, in the work and out of it. Don’t look away. Because I would. And then I would look back.


It’s a strange time to be writing it. Caring about strangers has become something you’re supposed to be a little ashamed of. You can hear it from the top, and lately I hear it in the way people around here talk. The language is changing. It found its way into the song.


There’s a market for the hating

There’s a fortune in the fear

They call it weakness now to feel

What someone’s feeling here


The video is a slideshow set to the song. For every photograph in it, I looked at hundreds of others. The question every time was whether this one was too much. Would it make people look away? There’s a thin line between making it real and making it too real, and the only guide I had was my own judgment, biases and all. That’s the bottom line in any documentary. Somebody decides what you get to see. The song knows that too.


They film it from the heavens

With a sad song underneath


That’s what I made.


Most of the photographs come from aid organizations that want them seen, and from photographers working on their own to get them out. Some are mine, from the camps, and in every one of mine a child is looking straight into the lens. They are not there to invoke sympathy. They are there to show what is important.


Near the end come World Central Kitchen crews in disaster zones and the people they feed. A small boy in a refugee camp holding a plastic bottle. Then her.


It isn’t a reminder of what’s going on in the world. It’s pointing at something I can’t quite see yet.


Uncounted


I’ve tried to follow so many of these stories. Syria. Nepal. Gaza, where very few will use the word genocide. Sudan, where people have been starving for years. Each one gets a few days of horror, and then the next one comes along.


Some of it is hidden by the news cycle. Some of it is hidden by simply not counting. The Global Report on Food Crises is the closest thing we have to a census of the hungry. Its 2026 edition found about 266 million people in 47 countries in acute hunger, fewer than the year before. The drop isn’t real. Eighteen countries couldn’t produce usable data, the worst coverage in the report’s ten years. It’s hard to think of a quieter way to tell people not to look.


Here is what still gets counted. Globally, about one person in ten lives on less than three dollars a day. One in seventy has been forced from home, and 39 percent of them are children. In October 2026 the World Food Programme cut half a million people in Gaza off food aid because the money hadn’t come in. Families who were getting two parcels a month now get one, with smaller bags of flour.


And here is what it would cost. Food and cooking fuel for the hundred thousand people in the Thai border camps runs about $1.3 million a month, according to the agency that supplies them. That’s about forty cents a person a day. Call it $16 million a year. Going into 2026, more than 80 percent of those refugees were told they would get no food aid at all. In 2025, according to Oxfam, the world’s billionaires added $2.5 trillion to their fortunes. At $16 million a year, that would feed the camps for more than 150,000 years.


In October the World Food Programme said it needed $450 million to keep feeding Gaza for six months. This election season, Elon Musk spent $445 million on federal races, by OpenSecrets’ count.


So the money isn’t the problem. That leaves the question I keep coming back to: why would anyone want people to care less?


Permission


In February 2025 Musk sat down with Joe Rogan and said, “The fundamental weakness of Western civilization is empathy.” He called it the empathy exploit, a bug that other people were using against us. In fairness, he also said he believes in empathy, as long as it’s empathy for civilization as a whole. Earlier that month he had posted that he spent the weekend “feeding USAID into the wood chipper.” By then the hospitals in the Thai border camps had already closed.


The phrase he leaned on, suicidal empathy, comes from Gad Saad, whose book by that name became a number one bestseller this year with Musk’s praise on the cover. It’s worth looking at what Saad actually blames. One chapter traces socialism, the welfare state and what he calls the nanny state back to suicidal empathy. So this isn’t really an argument about feelings. It’s an argument about who gets fed.


That’s the seed of it, I think. Compassion makes a claim on you. If that girl is real to you, then $1.3 million a month for the camps is your business, and so are the fortunes sitting somewhere else. Seeing someone means you owe them something. If you’re the one holding the money, the cheapest thing in the world is to convince people that the seeing is a sickness.


JD Vance does the same work more politely, and in the language of the church. In January 2025, answering criticism of the administration’s deportations on Fox News, he described an old Christian idea: “you love your family and then you love your neighbor, and then you love your community,” then your country, and after that the rest of the world. He called it ordo amoris, the order of love. It draws a circle and excuses you from everyone outside it.


Less than two weeks later the pope answered him. In a letter to the American bishops, Francis wrote that “Christian love is not a concentric expansion of interests that little by little extend to other persons and groups.” The true order of love, he said, is the one you find in the parable of the Good Samaritan, the story of a man who stops for a stranger on the road.


The argument for the smaller circle isn’t new. In 1798 Thomas Malthus argued that England’s poor laws “create the poor which they maintain,” that relief only bred more paupers. Half a century later, during the Irish famine, the Treasury official in charge of relief was Charles Trevelyan, who had studied under Malthus. Trevelyan wrote that the real evil to contend with was “not the physical evil of the Famine, but the moral evil of the selfish, perverse and turbulent character of the people.” Relief was cut back. Food kept leaving Irish ports. Around a million people died of hunger and the fevers that came with it.


The word that keeps coming back is dependency. Malthus thought relief made paupers. Trevelyan thought it taught the Irish to lean on the state. In October, the head of FEMA told a private conference in Arkansas that the administration plans to hand disaster response back to the states. “Federal dollars should be building greater capability,” he said, “not creating greater dependency.” In 2022 alone, the Census Bureau counted 3.3 million American adults forced from their homes by natural disasters. The survey only counted adults. It didn’t count the children.


The word only ever seems to point down. In 2010, when Tesla needed money, it got a $465 million federal loan. Musk paid it back. That was one piece. By The Washington Post’s count, his companies have taken in at least $38 billion in public money over two decades, in contracts, loans, subsidies and tax credits. Whatever it bought, it was tax money flowing into private companies, their payrolls and their owners. Nobody called any of it dependency.


Foreign aid gets the same treatment. Asked last year, Americans guessed it took about a quarter of the federal budget. It’s about one percent. And much of the food it sent was grown here. Food for Peace has bought more than a million metric tons of American crops over the years, and when the buying stopped, farm towns felt it. “The loss of foreign aid is the loss of a market for farmers’ surplus,” a Nebraska bean farmer said.


The argument always turns up at the same moment, when there is food and someone has decided not to share it. It turns withholding into discipline. Musk’s blurb for Saad’s book says what’s needed are actions that are “hard but necessary.”


It has reached the churches. In 2023 Russell Moore, an evangelical editor, said pastors kept telling him the same story. One would quote “turn the other cheek” from the pulpit, and afterward someone would ask where he had picked up those liberal talking points. When the pastor said it was Jesus, he was told that doesn’t work anymore. It’s weak.


It would be easy to stop there and blame the man in the pew. But the argument works on people because it offers something they already want. Not looking costs nothing. Being told you don’t have to care is a relief, and I know that relief. I kept a file closed for years. Nobody has to talk us into indifference. All the movement has to do is tell us our indifference is a virtue.


I honestly don’t know what some people see when they look at suffering that forty cents a day could ease. I know what I saw when I didn’t open that file. It wasn’t hatred. It was the cost of remembering. Maybe theirs is the same flinch, with a fortune behind it and a theory to make it sound like wisdom. I don’t know. But the flinch is mine too, which is the only reason I can recognize it.


July 31


Some of the people I met in the camps had been there thirty years or more. The camps go back to the mid-1980s, built for people running from the Burmese military, and people are still running. Since the 2021 coup, more have come.


In January 2025, when the US froze foreign aid, the camp hospitals shut. On July 31, food aid for ordinary households ended in all nine camps. That was more than 80 percent of families. There is less now to feed and shelter the people still arriving, and the people who have spent their whole lives there.


And still there are people who won’t look away. In the camps, it’s the refugees themselves who kept the clinics running after the money left, and who teach the children. Everywhere else it’s the aid workers, the doctors and the nurses who keep going in, and it costs them. In 2024, 387 aid workers were killed, more than in any year on record. That’s more than one a day, every day, for a year. Seven of them were with World Central Kitchen, hit by Israeli drone fire in Gaza while moving a shipment of food. In 2025, another 350 aid workers were killed, 186 of them in Gaza.


Watch


I know where I look away in this. I know which pictures bring tears. I’m not going to tell you where. Those places are yours to find.


“Don’t Look Away” Written & Performed by Gael MacLean - Photo credits at the end of this post.

Thursday


Thursday is food bank day here.


In July 2025 Congress passed the law the president called the One Big Beautiful Bill. Among other things, it widened SNAP’s work requirements to people up to age 64, parents whose youngest child is 14, veterans, and people with no home. Most SNAP recipients who can work already do. The rule is eighty hours a month, every month, and low-wage hours don’t come that steadily.


Between July 2025 and June 2026, more than 5 million Americans lost SNAP, about 2 million of them children. That’s more than twice the population of Idaho. By June, participation had fallen to its lowest point since 2009, and the economy hasn’t gotten any better.


It gets worse from here. Starting in October 2027, states will have to pay part of the benefits themselves for the first time, and states with higher error rates will pay more. An error means paying a family the wrong amount, too much or too little. Turning a family away by mistake doesn’t count. That gives every state a reason to say no first. Some may drop out of SNAP altogether. On November 10, the administration proposed a rule that would cut another 6.3 million people off SNAP, by its own count. The public can comment until December 10.


The same law cut taxes. The Congressional Budget Office worked out what the whole law means, year after year, through 2034. The poorest tenth of American households lose about $1,200 a year, 3.1 percent of their income. The richest tenth gain about $13,600.


Put that in months. The same law takes about a hundred dollars a month from the households with the least, and leaves the households with the most about eleven hundred dollars a month better off.


Why is that okay?


None of this is charity being taken back. SNAP, Medicaid and FEMA are programs Congress created and people pay for, out of every paycheck, so the help is there when their turn comes. The money being cut was never Washington’s to keep. It was the people’s.


And cutting the help doesn’t make the need go away. Push people off SNAP and Medicaid and some of them fall into exactly the poverty those programs were built to prevent, just when the help is gone.


Food banks are supposed to catch what falls through. They can’t. For every meal a food bank hands out, SNAP provides nine. Last year the federal government canceled truckloads of food already ordered for Idaho food banks, more than 370,000 pounds of it. Donations have dwindled.


We call the people who come in patrons, and we treat them that way. The first thing most of them ask at check-in now is “Is there any meat?”


Most times there isn’t anymore.


Where She Is Now


She would be older now. She might be one of the very few accepted by another country. She might be teaching in the camps; they work hard to educate the children there. She might be dead.


I don’t know.



Back Matter


Don’t Look Away can be shared on its own. It’s on Vimeo and YouTube.


Pass it on.


Photos:

⁂

SOURCES:


Substack logo on black background, with an orange icon and gray wordmark.

Read on Substack

©2026 Gael MacLean


bottom of page